Fafo: Home

blank

About Fafo
Research
Staff
Publications
Search
Norsk
Log in

Fafo blank

228

Jon M. Hippe

Bargaining, Politics, and Solidarity: A Different Story?

A Study of Employment Relations and Occupational Welfare in Norway
Doctoral dissertation

ISBN 82-7422-192-3
1997 448 p NOK 320,- Order no: 228 pil Order

Web edition (pdf - 32MB) * More publications on this subject

The Norwegian case offers an opportunity to tell a different story of occupational welfare. Opposed to what is conventionally perceived, this works argues that occupational welfare plays an important role in the Norwegian welfare state and that, in certain periods, the growth of these arrangements has been a precondition for an expansion of public social policy programs. The study offers an analysis of the historical development of occupational welfare and its interplay with public programs as well as an analysis of why such benefits are offered by private sector companies. Among the conclusions drawn are:

  • Employee benefits that can be closely linked to social policy schemes (i.e. occupational welfare) show increasing importance as a form of remuneration and do form a distinct part of indirect remuneration
  • The provision of occupational welfare benefits is determined by factors internal to the firm, such as the organizations of labor relations, the system of wage bargaining and personnel policies. Employers tend to adjust their welfare strategies when unions enter the picture
  • The relationship between private and public welfare provision has been far from mechanical in the way that traditional theories of substitution could lead one to think. The substitution effect is to a large extent dependent on the nature of labor market institution

This analysis of occupational welfare indicate a revised understanding of how the Norwegian welfare state came to be far from a heroic version of welfare state development as a result of a grand strategic plan in which a homogenous labor movement consolidates its political power and quite simply legislates the “new society”.

 

Contents

Preface

PART 1 Introduction and theoretical perspectives

Chapter 1 Introduction _ trade unions, industrial relations, and occupational welfare
1.1 The research problem
1.2 Defining occupational welfare
1.3 Locating occupational welfare in the framework of welfare state and industrial relations research
1.4 The welfare state concept
1.5 Research design and data.

Chapter 2 Perspectives on the public_private mix in welfare state research
2.1 The puzzle: Understanding the logic of welfare state development
2.2 The logic of industrialism and capitalism
2.3 The social democratic model
2.4 Politics matters _ Alternative interpretations
2.5 Welfare State Regimes
2.6 Welfare Pluralism
2.7 Welfare State Research and the Public_Private Interplay

Chapter 3 Trade unions and social policy choices _ exit, voice and loyalty
3.1 Introduction _ the gap between micro_ and macro_ explanations.
3.2 Historical context _the political and economic effects of unionism?
3.4 Macro_oriented perspectives on union action
3.5 Micro_ oriented approaches to unionism
3.6 Unions and social policy _ the value of loyalty.

PART 2 The public - private interplay

Chapter 4 The development of occupational welfare in Norway
4.1 Introduction
4.2 The private_public mix in the early phases of modern social policy
4.3 Occupational welfare after the war
4.4 The development of occupational welfare 1954 _ 1988
4.5 Bargaining against markets
4.6 Conclusion _ dynamic social policy

Chapter 5 Do public pension systems influence the growth of private pensions?
A comparison of Denmark and Norway
5.1 Introduction
5.2 Specifying the research question
5.3 The structure of public pensions
5.5 Conclusion

Chapter 6 Trade unions and three crossroads of Norwegian pension politics
6.1 Introduction: A broadening of the analytical perspective.
6.2 Crossroad 1: The fight over universalism
6.3 Crossroad 2: Income relation and social inequality
6.4 Crossroad 3: Early retirement pensions _ Bargaining or politics?
6.5 Conclusion: Dynamic social policy

PART 3 The nature of employee benefit provision

Chapter 7 The invisible handshake _ Perspectives on occupational welfare provision
7.1 Introduction
7.2 Does the firm matter?
7.3 Internal labor markets and employee benefits.
7.4 A closer look at employer motives
7.5 Employee demand
7.6 Can unions boost benefit provision?
7.7 Elements of the invisible handshake.
7.8 A methodological note

Chapter 8 Employee benefits in the Norwegian labor market - There is more than meets the eye
8.1 Introduction
8.2 The welfare menu
8.3 Recent developments
8.4 Voluntary or contractual schemes?
8.5 Identifying dimensions of employee benefits
8.6 Conclusion

Chapter 9 The social policy of the Norwegian firm - explaining the variation in benefit provision
9.1 Introduction
9.2 A methodological note
9.3 The distributional pattern
9.4 Explaining company welfare benefit provision in private companies
9.5 A mutual underlying logic in benefit provision?
9.5 Conclusion _ the social policy of the Norwegian firm

Chapter 10 Attitudes on occupational welfare arrangements and union strategies
10.1 Introduction
10.2 The value and quality of pension rights
10.3 Information and control
10.4 Policy strategies
10.5 Conclusion

PART 4 Conclusion

Chapter 11 Conclusion
11.1 Politics, bargaining and Solidarity
11.2 The six research questions and the Norwegian story
11.3 Can general conclusions be drawn?
11.4 A comment on policy implications

Appendix
Bibliography